5 Musical Theater Audition Mistakes You Can’t Afford

In a musical theater audition it can seem like there’s very little you can control, but there are some elements that you can. Here are five things to avoid at your next musical theater audition and why your audition will suffer if you don’t.


Making your accompanist’s job harder.

Every audition song is a duet. Smart actors make their accompanist’s job easy so they can play their best for you; your audition depends on it. Give your accompanist a clean copy of your music containing only what you want them to play and what you are going to sing. Put it in non-glare sheet protectors in a three ring binder so there’s no weird reflection from rehearsal studio lighting, and it won’t fall off the piano as they turn pages.

It should be in the key you want. The name of the song, the composer, and the name of the show—if it’s from a show—should be at the top. It’s also a good idea to have a brief indication of the style written above the first bar (a rock ballad, for example). If they’re not familiar with the song, all of this information will help them understand the feel you want. Tempo or key changes should be clearly marked or highlighted so they’ll see them coming; you’ll want to point these out to them before you sing. Quietly but clearly give them the tempo you want before you begin. And please don’t forget to thank them!

Not warming up.

Most singers warm up their voices before they sing but many forget their body is connected to their voice. Warm up your body first and your voice will warm up faster! This is great news when you have a heavy performance or rehearsal load. Tension is a singer’s worst enemy and releasing tension in your body frees up your vocals without having to sing a note.

Along with inhibition and lack of specificity, failing to do a physical warmup is also partially to blame for the “no lower body” syndrome I see in so many singers who sing from the waist, but are disconnected below that. A physical warmup incorporating your whole body is a step in the right direction.

Believing your audition is about singing.

In an audition, a great voice is a plus, but what gets you the job is how effectively you communicate who you are through your song. That means your acting is at least—if not more—important than your singing. A lot of people can sing, but the performers who have something to say are the ones that move us. The singer-actor’s job is to understand, embody, and express a need in the lyric in a way that’s their own by using their heart, mind, body, and voice. Neglect this hugely important part of your audition and you’re just another actor who can sing a pretty song.

Lack of mental preparation.

If you don’t believe in yourself, who will? When you go to an audition leave your baggage at home. Not your backpack, but your insecurities, pessimism, self-criticism, and belief that you’re not really good enough. None of that will help you. Plan your strategy for how you will take control of your thoughts and focus your energy positively. You are not the first person to have issues and fears about auditioning. Stop making excuses and start conquering them. The tools are available. Start by researching them online or finding a great coach who can teach you how you can prepare to be your best self in the audition room. Soon you’ll be on the fast track to reaching your career goals.

Choosing inappropriate songs.

Make sure what you’re singing is appropriate for the show you’re auditioning for, as well as for your age and type. Don’t bring “Jesus of Suburbia” from “American Idiot” to an audition for “Oklahoma!,” and don’t bring “Oh, What a Beautiful Mornin’, ” from “Oklahoma!” to an audition for “American Idiot”—even if you sing them well. Likewise, if you’re in your late 30s and still singing “Much More” from “The Fantasticks,” it’s probably time to find a new song. And don’t sing “I’m Still Here” or “Rose’s Turn” if you’re 16 years old. Also, avoid profanity for auditions. Yes, we’re all adults but it’s your first impression. Why risk offending anyone?

To help you make all the right moves at your next musical theater audition I created “How to Choose an Audition Song,” a free guide you can download here.



All my best,


Philip Hernandez is a respected acting teacher and singing coach in NYC. He is also the only actor in Broadway history to play both Jean Valjean and Inspector Javert in Les Miserables. He created principal roles in Broadway’s Kiss of the Spiderwoman and Paul Simon’s The Capeman. You may also know him from his many television appearances: The Blacklist, Gotham, Blue Bloods, The Path, Bull, Nurse Jackie, Elementary, Person of Interest, Law and Order, Hostages and Damages to name a few. For information about acting lessons CLICK HERE or singing lessons CLICK HERE

Follow him on twitter @philip24601, on Instagram @philip24601 and on Facebook at @philip24601.

3 thoughts on “5 Musical Theater Audition Mistakes You Can’t Afford

  • Amadou

    I believe that you work hard for it , and you giving like this, I remembered your story transition , where you are for being the best your work hard make you the best, your everything audition tips very unique, your audition tips sounds like good prepared for the universe, when you have something and is like this is it, even many has but yours is already great, don’t know exactly doing with your soul and never stop it always pay I already feel lot different more confident, my experience let me be good what ever come to me and I like.
    I have done a lot greats with my soul, for not expecting enything, now I’m understanding this life am glad I did!

  • Carol Siegel

    I think this is great advice! I am a theatre teacher at Island Trees High School in Levittown, NY and I always look for articles like these to help my students. Thank you!

Comments are closed.